The Tick-Tock Tractatus
Speaking of Time: The Investigations
By Michael P. GarofaloFootnotes, Books, Links, Comments, Remarks
Tick-Tock Tractatus: Footnotes, Remarks, Comments
Speaking of Time: The Investigations
Key to Book Titles
BBB = Blue and Brown Books by Ludwig Wittgenstein, 1937
BTS = Big Typscript TS213 by Ludwig Wittgenstein, 2005
BU = Bundled Up, Volumes 1 - 6 by Mike Garofalo, 2021-2026
HRW = How to Read Wittgenstein by Ray Monk, 2005
PI = Philosophical Investigations by Ludwig Wittgenstein, 1953
PT = Poetry of Thought by George Steiner, 2011
TLP = Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus by Ludwig Wittgenstein, 1922
TTT = Tick-Tock Tractatus by Mike Garofalo, 2026
BTS = The Big Typscript TS213. By Ludwig Wittgenstein, 2005
Notes, Footnotes, Books, Links, Comments
Research, Related, Remarks, Ideas
1.
1.1.1
Title
BU3155
1.1.2
Title
BU3318
1.2
Title
1.2.1
Title
BU 3155
1.2
Title
1.2.1
Title
BU3155
1.2.2
Title
BU3316
1.3
Title
1.4
Title
1.5
Title
1.6
Title
1.5
Title
BU3452
1.6 BU2769
Entropy Points Its Finger
Entropy
Laws of Thermodynamics
1.7 BU 2767
The Sun Shows Time
1.7 BU 2767
The Sun Shows Time
1.7.2
The Shifting Faces of Time
BU2984
BBB Blue Book: p. 20, 26, 106
What is Time. Expectations. Before/After.
BBB Brown Book: #52-56
PI: #599
Monk: p. 338
The Language of Time, by Quentin Smith.
Oxford University Press, 1993, 272 pages.
"This book offers a defense of the tensed theory of time, a critique of the New Theory of Reference, and an argument that simultaneity is absolute. Although Smith rejects ordinary language philosophy, he shows how it is possible to argue from the nature of language to the nature of reality. Specifically, he argues that semantic properties of tensed sentences are best explained by the hypothesis that they ascribe to events temporal properties of futurity, presentness, or pastness and do not merely ascribe relations of earlier than or simultaneity. He criticizes the New Theory of Reference, which holds that "now" refers directly to a time and does not ascribe the property of presentness. Smith does not adopt the old or Fregean theory of reference but develops a third alternative, based on his detailed theory of de re and de dicto propositions and a theory of cognitive significance. He concludes the book with a lengthy critique of Einstein's theory of time. Smith offers a positive argument for absolute simultaneity based on his theory that all propositions exist in time. He shows how Einstein's relativist temporal concepts are reducible to a conjunction of absolutist temporal concepts and relativist nontemporal concepts of the observable behavior of light rays, rigid bodies, and the like."
3.2.1
BU2652
3.2.2
BU3338
Truths about the Future?
5.4
BU2590
Counting the Moons Over La Push
Growth is time embodied.
The Psychology of Human Temprality
by
David Gilden, 2025
8.4.1
Title
BU3431
9.3.1
Did the Demons Listen
9.3.2
Title
BU3102
9.3.3
"I have written down all these thoughts as remarks, short
paragraphs, sometimes in longer chains about the same
subject, sometimes jumping, in a sudden change, from
one area to another."
- Ludwig Wittgenstein, Philosophical Investigations, Preface
"A Man may make a Remark---
In itself ---
A quiet thing
That may furnish
The Fuse unto a Spark
In dormant nature--- lain ---
Let us deport --- with skill ---
Let us discourse --- with care ---
Powder exists in Charcoal ---
Before it exists in Fire."
- Emily Dickinson, ED#952
Emily Dickinson, 1860-1886, ED#952
Remarks in Wittgenstein's Style
Speech Acts: An Essay in the Philosophy of Language.
By John R. Searle, 1969.
10.2
Title
"The force of silence is that of a dying echo of language.
It is possible to love silently,
but perhaps only up to a point.
Authentic speechlessness comes with death.
To die is to stop chattering."
- George Steiner, The Poetry of Thought
Time, Metaphor and Language. By Sarah E. Duffy, 1993.
Through the Language Glass:
How the World Looks Different in Other Languages
By Guy Deutscher, 2010.
An Introduction to the Philosophy of Language.
By Michael Morris, 2006.
Philosophy of Time. By Sean Edna Power, 2021.
Time Explained: Experience, Consciousness and Relativity.
By
Alan Bennett, 2026.
Why Does Language Matter to Philosophy. By Ian Hacking, 1975.
The Philosophy of Time. Edited by Robin le Poidevin, 1993.
Thinking in Time: An Introduction to Henri Bergson.
By Suzanne Guerlac, 2006.
The Tensed Theory of Time: A Critical Examination.
By William Lane Craig, 2000.
The Oxford Handbook of the Philosophy of Time.
Edited by Craig Callender, 2013.
A Brief History of the Philosophy of Time.
By Adrian Bardon, 2024.
A Companion to the Philosophy of Time.
Edited by Heather Dyke, Blackwell, 2015.
An Introduction to the Philosopy of Time.
By
Sam Baron and Kristie Miller, 2018.
Time and Philosophy: A History of Continental Thought.
By John McCumber,
2011.
Out of Time: A Philosophy Study of Timelessness.
By Sam Baron and Kristie Miller, 2022.
In Search of Time: The History, Physics and Philosopy of Time.
By Dan Falk, 2010.
11.2
Title
"For countless mortals music, however vaguely,
comes closer than any other felt presence to inferring,
to forecasting the possible reality of transcendence.
of an encounter with the numinous, with the
supernatural as these lie beyond empirical reach."
- George Steiner, The Poetry of Thought
12.2
Title
13.2
Title
14.2
Title
15.6
Title
Structure of Scientific Revolutions by Thomas Kuhn 1962
Charles Darwin, The Origin of Species
16.2
Title
Preface

Miscellaneous Notes
I had
a habit of smoking
in my cold garage
in a well-lit corner
reading Wittgenstein's Remarks, entranced.
Were they remarks, analogies, descriptions?
Were they analogies, asides, staged discussions?
Were they intellectual artillery against an enemy?
Were they charms that attracted followers?
Were they Results, Propositions, Rules?
Where are the Places in his living cosmos ...
Like Norway, Vienna, Cambridge? No!
Dismantle, Reassemble, Restructure
Point out, Listen attentively, Touch things gently
Untangle yourself from Essences
Explore the Grammar of Consciousness
Unpeel the Onion Layers: [Smells so Fresh]
Just juggling gems of logical arguments with himself,
Drowning at times in the depths of Socratic despair,
Hanging on, Fighting through, a soldier of Duty to the Death,
Never publishing again after 1922, Hesitant! Doubtful.
Always entangled in a lingering linguistic mess.
Discovering his Remarks and compact essays,
On a variety of intriguing matters and themes,
Captivated a young graduate student like me,
In those past 1975 days and in decades beyond it seemed.
The compactness, the brevity, the focused attention,
The questioning then answering, the courage then the faltering,
The clarity opening up suddenly, then drowning in a Wordy Sea.
A bluntness, directness, authoritarianism, and macho manly veteran style.
Slipping away as his last days faded,
and a few students took up his crusades.
His later style wandered in the nettles of philosophical poetry.
Anyone stung by the bees of stupidity, received no mercy from he.
But the studious and scholarly few in his Cambridge classes,
Like Gertrude Elizabeth Margaret Anscombe,
Helped us understand this German-English speaking thinker's mind.
But he thought himself that he failed miserably.
Gertrude Elizabeth Margaret Anscombe
Ludwig Wittgenstein (1889-1951)

Index to Bundled Up Quintains Related to Time:
# 2504, 2505, 2509, 2513, 2516, 2522, 2547, 2583,
#
2590, 2597, 2617, 2622, 2623, 2643, 2648, 2649
# 2652, 2663,2685, 2727, 2728, 2733, 2739, 2757
#
2767, 2768, 2769, 2831, 2858, 2864, 2866, 2872, 2890, 2891
#
2891, 2892, 2932, 2988, 2995, 3007, 3012, 3013, 3073
#
3102, 3103, 3120, 3127, 3155
# 3233, 3269, 3316, 3323, 3338, 3431, 3438, 3452, 3481
The Tick-Tock Tractatus by Mike Garofalo
Index to Bundled Up Quintains Related to Wittgenstein:
#154, 155, 160, 233, 544, 846, 854, 1294, 1665, 1714, 2178
#
2427, 2501, 2643, 2645, 2654, 2675,
2687, 2688, 2723, 2730
#
2733, 2735, 2760, 2751, 2757, 2788, 2793,
2796, 2800, 2806
# 2808, 2854, 2850, 2855, 2863, 2864, 2876, 2920,
#
2928, 2935, 2983, 2989

Bundled Up:
Quintains, Tankas, Pentastichs, and Onions
Original Quintain Poetry By Mike Garofalo
Bundled Up, Volume 1
Quintain Poems 1 - 1,000
Bundled Up, Volume 2
Quintain Poems 1,000 - 1,500
Bundled Up, Volume 3
Quintain Poems 1,500 - 2,000
Bundled Up, Volume 4
Quintain Poems 2,000 - 2,500
Bundled Up, Volume 5
Quintain Poems 2,500 - 3,000
Bundled Up, Volume 6
Quintain Poems 3,000 - 3,500
Quintains: 2,500+ Quintains (Free Online)
Quintain Sonnet Forms ( 5252, 555, 553 )
Quintains: Bibliography, Links, Notes
Quintains: Cloud Hands Blog Posts

25 Steps and Beyond: Collected Works
At the Edges of the West
Highway 101 and Hwy 1
Bundled Up: Quintains, Pentastichs, Tankas
Cuttings: Haiku, Senryu, Brief Poems
At the Edges of the Fertile West
Highway 99 and Interstate 5
Texts Press Publications
Free Online Poetry and Studies
Vancouver, Washington
Texts Press Email

Quintains and Tanka Poetry
Research, Studies, Notes
Bibliography, Links, References,
Webpages, Essays, Magazines
Definitions, Examples
Research by Mike Garofalo
Mike Garofalo's Internet
Web Publishing
Objectives, Aims, and Policies:
Provide open access to people worldwide.
People can read my poetry for free: 24/7.
Google translate drop-down menu included.
No advertising or pop-up ads on my webpages.
No cookies log-in steps.
No irrelevant graphics.
No AI generated ads!
No requests for your email before reading.
Not promoting chapbooks or
books of mine or from others to sell.
Since 2024, my webpages are in
CSS format and cellphone readable.
I use my Cloud Hands Blog for
poetry posts, posts on a variety
of topics, promoting others,
and selling books.
I research and study poetry at my home.
In 2026, I am carefully studying
the poetry of
John Ashbery,
Emily Dickinson, and the West Coast,
USA, Literary Scene, Quintains,
and Ludwig Wittgenstein.
My academic background includes:
philosophy, information science,
librarianship, education, and business.
Feedback or suggestions are welcome.
Editors and publishers who think my
poetry has some commercial possibilities
for themselves
are encouraged
to contact me.
I've been employed as a webmaster,
grant writer, and web publisher
since 1998.
25 Steps and Beyond:
The Collected Works of Mike Garofalo
Texts PreSS Couve Publications
Free Online Poetry and Studies
By Mike Garofalo
Vancouver, Washington
Text PreSS Couve Email


Michael Peter Garofalo (1946-) grew up in East Los Angeles,
raised well by my parents June and Big Mike, was educated
in Catholic Schools, lived with two other brothers, graduated
(B.A., M.S.) from local universities.
Married Blanche Karen Eubanks, served in the US Air Force,
worked in and managed many City and Los Angeles County
Public Libraries, raised two children, socialized, traveled,
and learned. Retired as the Regional Administrator, East
Region, Los Angeles County Public Library in 1998.
We moved to a rural 5 acre property in Red Bluff, in the
North Sacramento Valley, CA. Webmaster since 1998.
Worked part-time for the Corning School District
(Technology and Media Services Manager, District
Librarian, Grant Writer, Webmaster); and as a yoga,
Taijiquan, and fitness club instructor until 2016.
Traveled extensively in Northern California,
Oregon, and Washington.
We both retired, and we moved to Vancouver, WA, in 2017.
Currently in 2025: reading, writing, gardening, harmonica
playing, home chores, yurt camping, exercise, traveling
in the Northwest, web publishing, family events, poetry
research, photography, Northwest research, Nature
mysticism, Buddhist and Taoist literature, walking,
sports events, etc.
25 Steps and Beyond; Collected Works
I really appreciate positive feedback,
reviews, kudos, and encouragement
about the value
of
my free webpages.
Send your comments to:
Text Press Email
Bundled Up:
Quintains, Pentastichs,
Tankas, and Onions

Poetry By Michael P. Garofalo
Pulling Onions
1,000 Quips, Opinions, and One-Liners
A Basket of Ideas from the Backyard
Cuttings :::
Tercets, Haiku, Senryu, and Onions
Arranged by Months
Bundled Up:
Quintains, Tankas, Pentastichs, and Onions
Original Quintain Poetry By Mike Garofalo
Bundled Up, Volume 1
Quintain Poems 1 - 1,000
Bundled Up, Volume 2
Quintain Poems 1,000 - 1,500
Bundled Up, Volume 3
Quintain Poems 1,500 - 2,000
Bundled Up, Volume 4
Quintain Poems 2,000 - 2,500
Bundled Up, Volume 5
Quintain Poems 2,500 - 3,000
Quintains: 2,500+ Quintains (Free Online)
Quintain Sonnet Forms ( 5252, 555, 553 )
Quintains: Bibliography, Links, Notes
Quintains: Cloud Hands Blog Posts

At the Edges of the West
A Docu-Poem
The earliest poems on this webpage
were posted online in 2021.
This document was last edited, revised,
reformatted, added to, relinked,
changed, improved, or modified
by Mike Garofalo
on March 3, 2026.